Epiphany Dermatology – Peachtree City

RESEARCH-BASED REVIEW, NOT A FIRST-HAND VISIT. Everything below comes from the public sources listed at the end, accessed on 2026-10-11. No one from Peachtree City Guide has been a patient here or contacted the practice. Criteria that need first-hand experience are scored from public signals and are provisional.

⚕️ Health disclaimer: This review covers patient experience and public records only. It does not assess clinical quality and is not medical advice. Confirm insurance/network status and each provider’s license and credentials yourself before booking. No patient health information is included; we only summarize public review themes.

License status: MD/DO names were matched against the Georgia Composite Medical Board’s published physician list (CSV dated 9/11/2026; the board says license number and status on its site are primary-source verification). Name matches can be wrong, and the board’s individual lookup is CAPTCHA-protected, so we did not use it. Dentists, optometrists, chiropractors, physical therapists and nurse practitioners are licensed through boards on verify.sos.ga.gov, which blocked automated access with a bot check; we did not get around it, so those licenses are marked unverified. Check any provider yourself at https://gateway.medicalboard.georgia.gov/ (physicians/PAs) or https://verify.sos.ga.gov/verification/ (other boards).

Scorecard

Score note (2026-10-11): first published draft under the Health & Medical rubric (site-plan.md §5.10). No earlier score.

Quick facts

• Address: 1975 Hwy 54 W, Suite 250, Peachtree City, GA 30269
• Phone: (470) 502-1119
• Website: https://www.epiphanydermatology.com/location/peachtree-city-ga/
• Hours: See location page
• Services: Medical, surgical and cosmetic dermatology (multi-state group)
• Insurance / payment: Insurance list published (includes Medicare and Tricare) and self-pay rates published (site).
• New patients / access: Same/next-day appointments (site). Same/next-day appointments.

The short version

• Credentials & good standing: 2 physicians name-matched Active on GCMB list; 4 PAs unverified.
• Patient reviews across platforms: Exa 4.9 / 1,568; Healthgrades 4.1 / 27.
• Access (new patients, hours, same-day/telehealth): Same/next-day.
• Transparency (insurance, pricing, policies): Insurance list and self-pay rates published.
• Complaint record & consistency: Group BBB C+ (other office).
• Longevity & local presence: Not stated.
• Recent patient experience: 8 dated reviews in the last 24 months read directly; compliments: bedside manner / caring (6), professional / knowledgeable (5), explains clearly / listens (3), helpful front desk (1); complaints: none found.

Providers (as published by the practice) and license checks

• Note: Providers from the PTC location page; the site notes “some providers may service multiple locations”. Dr. Jill Buckthal appears on the GCMB list as Jill Buckthal-McCuin.
• Note: A separate Epiphany listing in Newnan (4.9 / 2,111) is excluded.

What patients say (themes)

• Recent themes (last 24 months, n=8): compliments — bedside manner / caring (6), professional / knowledgeable (5), explains clearly / listens (3), helpful front desk (1); complaints — none found.
• We summarize themes only. We do not quote or repeat any reviewer’s health details.
• Limitation: we read only the reviews visible on each aggregator page (Exa Places’ Google-derived snapshot and Birdeye). Google, Yelp, Zocdoc and Facebook were not opened directly; Yelp and Zocdoc block automated access.

Credentials & red-flag check

Access, insurance & pricing

Insurance list published (includes Medicare and Tricare) and self-pay rates published (site). Same/next-day appointments (site).

Other review platforms (checked 2026-10-11)

Ratings from search-engine snippets are marked “unconfirmed” and never change a score. Health-system-published survey ratings (e.g., Piedmont’s own) are shown for context only.

What recent reviewers say (keyword analysis)

• Window: 2024-10-11 to 2026-10-11. Sample: 8 reviews read directly (Exa Places (Google-derived snapshot)).
• Top compliments: bedside manner / caring (6), professional / knowledgeable (5), explains clearly / listens (3), helpful front desk (1).
• Top complaints: none found.
• Recent-experience score (RCE): 8.5/10 (15 positive vs 0 negative theme mentions; fewer than 10 reviews are pulled toward a neutral 5).

Score breakdown (rubric §5.10 in site-plan.md)

The listed weights cover 90% of the score; recent patient experience (keyword analysis) covers the other 10%. Unknowns score 5 and are marked “not verified”. Research-based reviews are capped at 9.0. See /how-we-score/. | Criterion | Weight | Score | Evidence | |—|—|—|—| | Credentials & good standing | 20% | 7 | 2 physicians name-matched Active on GCMB list; 4 PAs unverified | | Patient reviews across platforms | 25% | 9 | Exa 4.9 / 1,568; Healthgrades 4.1 / 27 | | Access (new patients, hours, same-day/telehealth) | 20% | 8 | Same/next-day | | Transparency (insurance, pricing, policies) | 15% | 8 | Insurance list and self-pay rates published | | Complaint record & consistency | 10% | 6 | Group BBB C+ (other office) | | Longevity & local presence | 10% | 5 | Not stated | | Recent patient experience (keyword analysis, last 24 months) | 10% | 8.5 | n=8; 15 positive vs 0 negative theme mentions | | Overall | | 7.6 | 0.9 × 7.55 (weighted average of the rubric rows) + 0.1 × 8.53 = 7.65 |

Bottom line

Very large positive review base and the best price transparency in dermatology (published self-pay rates). Mostly PA-staffed; ask who you will see.

Sources (accessed 2026-10-11)

1. https://www.epiphanydermatology.com/location/peachtree-city-ga/
2. Exa Places (Google-derived snapshot, Sep 14 2026): https://exa.ai/library/place/8y9cfbsnh1f
3. BBB: https://www.bbb.org/us/ga/stockbridge/profile/dermatologist/epiphany-dermatology-0443-91834029
4. Georgia Composite Medical Board, physician list (Medical Malpractice Coverage as reported by Physicians, 9/11/2026): https://medicalboard.georgia.gov/document/document/medicalmalpracticecoverageforphysicians9-11-2026csv/download
5. GCMB monthly public board orders: https://medicalboard.georgia.gov/about-us/about-georgia-composite-medical-board/list-monthly-public-board-orders
6. Healthgrades provider search results (Peachtree City, GA), one query per listed provider.

Disclosure: no compensation, free service, or affiliate relationship. Not affiliated with the City of Peachtree City or the State of Georgia. This is not medical advice. Found an error? See /corrections. How we score: /how-we-score/.